Columns

The wrong formula

Some vow for rule changes to rattle the current "status quo". Driver's market is another hot topic.
Wednesday, November 20, 2013

November 20th, 2013 (F1plus/ R. Myers).- If you’re reading this, it’s pretty likely that you’re a Formula 1 fan. A fan of thrilling racing, overtaking, battles for the lead and the championship. A fan of motorsport at it’s very best. That’s what F1 is all about, after all; it’s the pinnacle of motorsport. Or, at least, that’s what it should be.

Sadly, Formula 1 has become increasingly dull. At the weekend we saw the now four time world drivers’ champion, Sebastian Vettel, take his eighth consecutive victory. As usual, he was pretty much unchallenged at the front and the win was comprehensive and straightforward. As usual, we heard team radio messages to various drivers urging them to conserve their Pirelli tyres. Yes, that’s right, team radio telling drivers not to push to the maximum for fear that they might wear out their tyres. The overtaking that we did see either happened at the start or was largely achieved with the assistance of the Drag Reduction System (DRS) overtaking aid. Is this really what we want racing to be like at the pinnacle of the sport?

I should be clear that none of this is Vettel’s fault. He’s clearly a great driver, who has the privilege of driving cars that have been the class of the field for the last four years.

Indeed, but for the Brawn double diffuser in 2009, there’s little doubt that Vettel and Red Bull Racing would have won five consecutive world drivers’ and constructors’ championships. No doubt, future generations will look at the record books and marvel at the German’s achievements, and no doubt, his fans love his complete dominance of Formula 1. For the rest of us, though, be we supporters of other drivers, or just fans of great racing, Vettel’s dominance is a real turn off.

What’s the point of watching a race when the outcome is all but certain?

The change in regulations in 2014 brings with it a huge opportunity for F1 to become exciting again. Non-Vettel/Red Bull fans are living in the hope that other teams and drivers will raise their games for 2014, and that the absence of the exhaust technology that Red Bull has mastered will level the playing field somewhat. I very much hope that it does, but even then there are other things that need to be addressed, chief among them the Pirelli tyres.

Again, I should preface my comments by saying that I don’t think the Pirelli are solely to blame for the problems that we’re now seeing. They must, though, shoulder some blame. When Pirelli entered F1 in 2011 they were asked to make tyres that degraded more rapidly than the Bridgestone rubber that had been used previously.

Typically races run on Bridgestone’s during the time that they were the sole tyre supplier, following the banning of refuelling, were one stop races, lacking in much excitement. Then the Canadian grand prix of 2010 came along, with multiple tyre stops as the rubber degraded more quickly, we had an exciting and tough to predict race. “This is the answer” thought the FIA, “faster wearing tyres produce better racing”. So that’s what Pirelli were asked to produce.

And that’s what Pirelli have produced. I would argue that they have taken their brief too far, but they have certainly done what the FIA asked them to do, and with very limited testing, too. What the FIA didn’t consider, though, was that rapidly degrading rubber is fine when it’s not the norm. When it’s unexpected it will produce racing that’s exciting.

The problem is, though, that everyone knows that the tyres wear out quickly. So, instead of pushing their cars and themselves to the limits – as they should be doing at the pinnacle of motorsport – they concern themselves with not overstressing their tyres. They’re not pushing hard. They’re not driving on the limit. They are protecting their tyres to try to achieve the optimum race strategy.

As a result, we don’t see much exciting wheel to wheel racing. There are no race long battles for the lead. Formula 1 in 2013 has become what the FIA had hoped to avoid – dull and uninteresting. If the FIA wants races with multiple pit stops it would be far better to have harder wearing tyres – tyres that drivers can really stress and push to the limit on – and mandatory pit stops. That would be better from a marketing point of view for the tyre manufacturer, and better for the sport.

 

Vettel won his 8th straight race this season, a new record in Formula 1. (Getty/Red Bull)

F1 is not really helped by DRS, the other big change, along with Pirelli tyres, at the start of 2011. DRS, to be fair, does help overtaking by reducing drag. As you probably know, it can only be used at set points at each track and only when a car is within a second of the car ahead of it at a set detection point. The problem with it is that it’s completely artificial.

We’ve become so used to DRS now, though. I find myself watching a DRS assisted pass during races and thinking, “great pass” or “good move” when it’s anything more than someone just driving past someone else in the middle of a straight. These aren’t great passes, though. They are manufactured and artificial. A far cry from the truly great overtaking manoeuvres of the past that we now see fewer and fewer of.

As I’ve written about previously, instead of dreaming up devices to artificially boost overtaking, the FIA need to concern themselves with addressing the aerodynamic rules that make it difficult for Formula 1 cars to follow each other closely. Resolve that, introduce mandatory pit stops and request harder wearing tyres, and we might see Formula 1 racing that’s exciting again.

Of course, not much can be done if one team or driver is just better than the rest, as we’ve seen over the past few seasons with Sebastian Vettel and Red Bull Racing. As I’ve said, it’s up to others to raise their game to make sure that it doesn’t happen again in 2014. They need some help from the rule-makers, though.

At the moment, the FIA have got the balance completely wrong. And when you add the ridiculousness of the driver market into the equation, the situation looks even bleaker. Increasingly, teams need drivers to pay their way, rather than earning their drives on the basis of talent alone.

There are a few exceptions to that rule, most notably McLaren’s recent promotion of Kevin Magnussen to a race seat in 2014, but others aren’t as lucky. The best example at the current time is Nico Hulkenberg. It looks increasingly likely that the talented German will be overlooked for a leading drive at Lotus because of his lack of sponsorship cash. Hulkenberg has performed wonders whichever team he has driven for in the past, but that’s not enough nowadays.

Instead it looks likely that the Lotus drive will go to Pastor Maldonado and his bucket-load of PVDSA sponsorship. The Venezuelan is quick on his day, but crash-prone, erratic and prone to red mist. As we saw in Austin, he’s also petulant and a poor loser. Certainly not a driver that’s worthy of one of the top drives in F1. Indeed, but for his sponsorship money I doubt he would have ever secured a drive in Formula 1.

I’m not sure what can be done about the rise of the pay driver in F1 but this, together with the lacklustre on track action does not make for a healthy sport. This is not the right formula for success. As they’d say in Star Trek, the F1 of 2013 “is Formula 1, Jim, but not as we know it”. Nor as we want it to be.

Your Comments

 

Formula 1 News

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

Mercedes on top in final 2014 practice

Wednesday, November 26, 2014

Vergne splits with Toro Rosso

F1plusStore

F1 Standings

Drivers
Teams
1 Lewis Hamilton 384
2 Nico Rosberg 317
3 Daniel Ricciardo 238
4 Valtteri Bottas 186
5 Sebastian Vettel 167
6 Fernando Alonso 159
1 Mercedes 701
2 Red Bull Racing 405
3 Williams F1 320
4 Ferrari 214
5 McLaren 187
6 Sahara Force India 152

View complete standings table »

F1plusStore

Last F1 Race

Abu Dhabi Grand Prix
Yas Island, Yas Marina Circuit
1
Lewis Hamilton
Mercedes
2
Felipe Massa
Williams F1
3
Valtteri Bottas
Williams F1
Fastest Lap

Daniel Ricciardo
1'44.496s

Pole Position

Nico Rosberg

View all »

 

Follow Us